Java J2EE Portal
Enterprise Java Station
J2EE curve
Java News / Articles
Java News / Articles
Continuous Integration - Agile Software Development Q & A
Happenings @ IndicThreads.com Conference On Java Technology 2007
spring Tutorial
Building Web Applications Using The Spring Framework
Processing...
Buy Java, Deals On Software Technology Store
Click here for great deals on computers, laptops, software and books
Software piracy: Lessons from US history PDF Print
Written by Harshad Oak   
Jan 31, 2005 at 02:04 PM
Just read an article that said that the US stand on intellectual property is hypocritical because its own prosperity was based on rampant piracy. The article provides a completely new perspective on piracy.
The article appeared in the Business World magazine  and is based on a book named Trade Secrets: Intellectual Piracy And The Origins of American Industrial Power written by Doron S. Ben-Atar and an interview with the author.

It talks about how American leaders supported piracy of European technology for centuries but once America became a world leader in technology, it switched to being an advocate of international laws regulating intellectual property. It goes on to say that "Nearly every branch of manufacture in the US was founded upon imported skill and machinery which was smuggled in because there were strict prohibitions in Europe"

The author suggests that the way leaders of developing nations should handle piracy issue today is by paying lip service to IP agreements and occasionally raid a warehouse full of pirated CDs or prosecute a high-profile pirate. That's because US history teaches us that symbolic acts and talk of principles, accompanied by lax enforcement, are a winning combination.

An interesting piracy fact is that the value of illegal software in the US is 6496 million dollars while that in China is 3822.5 million dollars. The figure in India is 367.4 million dollars. This is very strange considering that it's generally India and China that get all the blame for piracy. Even the UK has more than 4 times more illegal software than India. The UK figure is 1600.6 million dollars.

The author suggests that we have to learn to live with piracy and yet the way to the top is only through creating your own IP and not by copying. An interesting read, with lessons for both the developing as well as the developed world.

Ref:

  1. How to stop worrying and learn to live with piracy (requires free registration)
  2. Trade Secrets
  3. Global Piracy Study
  4. Trade Secrets Intellectual Piracy and the Origins of American Industrial Power

Related:

  1. Pirates of the IT world: The Curse of the Black Bazaar

User Comments

Comment by Guest on 2005-01-31 17:09:01
Unfortunately that is how the world works. Blame it on somebody least likely to resist.

Comment by harshad on 2005-01-31 18:29:53
The Developing Nations license is an interesting idea. It allows royalty-free use in developing nations while retaining full copyright in the developed world.  
 
http://creativecommons.org/license/devnations 
[URL=http://creativecommons.org/license/devnations]Developing Nations License[/URL] 
 
[URL=http://creativecommons.org/licenses/devnations/2.0/]Developing Nations 2.0[/URL]
Your Name / Email Address
Comment
Spam Protection - Please enter the code in the image -

Listen to code


Add This Feed Button

Enter your Email


Java Expert Interviews
RubyOnRailscreatorDavidHeinemeierHansson
Let Java retire from the spotlight of web applications in dignity
RoelStalmanOracleJDeveloper
JDeveloper is the most comprehensive Java IDE available
MarcDomenig
Swing UI is mature while Ajax is still in its infancy
Processing...
Go to top of page  Home |
SiteMap

Copyright 2004 to 2008 Rightrix Solutions. All rights reserved. All product names are trademarks of their respective companies. Java and all Java-based marks are trademarks or registered trademarks of Sun Microsystems, Inc. in the United States and other countries. Rightrix Solutions and IndicThreads.com are independent of Sun Microsystems, Inc.

Views expressed at IndicThreads.com reflect the views of the authors alone, and do not necessarily reflect those of IndicThreads.com. IndicThreads.com and it's authors are not responsible for reader comments and opinions.

Enterprise Java J2EE JEE Portal >> IndicThreads.com